69 Ocean Avenue (9.9 km from Fire Island Life Saving Station (historical))
Located 1969 feet from Benjamin's Memorial Beach The Ocean Bay House offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool a shared lounge and air-conditioned accommodations with a terrace and free WiFi. The accommodations features a spa bath.
501 East Main Street (11.1 km from Fire Island Life Saving Station (historical))
Located 1 mile from Fire Island National Seashore Travelodge Bay Shore Long Island offers free Wi-Fi and a fitness center to keep in shape.